ISSN: 2225-8329
Open access
This study compares the profitability of cooperatives and investor-owned firms in the Italian wine sector. From a review of the financial ratios that have traditionally been applied in previous studies, we identify the key factors that affect firm profitability (proxied by sales growth) and analyse them for the five-year period from 2008 to 2012. Italian wine cooperatives offer a particularly suitable environment in which to apply our study because they have benefitted from EU regulation and several supporting measures since 2008, allowing them to invest in infrastructure and improve efficiency in order to produce quality wine, grow their brands, and penetrate export markets. In particular, this study expands the body of knowledge on this topic by focusing on the factors that affect the profitability of cooperatives and investor-owned firms and by considering time series data. We find that the EU support measures for cooperatives have led to an increase in their financial performance since 2008. Moreover, cooperatives typically have lower liquidity levels and significantly high debt as a proportion of net equity compared with investor-owned firms. Hence, consistent with the findings in the literature, the influence of financial performance on profitability is clearly related to business type.
Akono, J. H., Nganje, W. E., Kaitibie, S., and Gustafson, C. R. (2005). Investors’ Expectations of New Generation Cooperatives Equity. Agribusiness and Applied Economics Report No: 575, North Dakota State University.
Arslan, Y. (2007). Financial Analysis of Afyon Sugarbeet Growers Cooperative. Msc Thesis, Eskisehir Anadolu University, pp. 135, Eskisehir.
Banaszak, I. (2007). Testing Theories of Cooperative Arrangements in Agricultural Markets, Results from Producer Groups in Poland. IAAE-104th EAAE Seminar, 6-8 September 2007, Corvinus University of Budapest, Hungary.
Baourakis, G., Doumpos, M., Kalogeras, N., and Zopounidis, C. (2002). Multicriteria Analysis and Assessment of Financial Viability of Agribusinesses: The Case of Marketing Cooperatives and Juice-Producing Companies. Agribusiness, 18(4): 543-558.
Barton, D., Schroeder, T. C., and Featherstone A. (1993). Evaluating the Feasibility of Local Cooperative Consolidations: A Case Study. Agribusiness, 9(3): 281-294.
Bianchini, S., Couderc, J. P., and Marchini, A. (2008). Wine Cooperatives Performance Determinants: A Comparative Analysis between Italy and France. Competitive paper, AIEA2 International Conference, Bologna, pp. 8-30.
Bijman, J., and Hanisch, M. (2012). Support for Farmers’ Cooperatives: Developing a typology of cooperatives and producer organisations in the EU. Wageningen: Wageningen UR.
Binion, R. W. (1998). Understanding Cooperative Bookkeeping and Financial Statements. USDA Cooperative Information Report, 57.
Boland, M. A., Golden, B., and Tsoodle, L. (2008). Agency Problems in the Food Processing Industry. Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics 40(2): 623-634.
Bonazzi, G., and Iotti, M. (2014). Agricultural Cooperative Firms: Budgetary Adjustments and Analysis of Credit Access Applying Scoring Systems. American Journal of Applied Sciences, 11(7): 1181-1192.
Boyd, S., Boland, M., Dhuyvetter, K., and Barton, D. (2007). Determinants of Return on Equity in U.S. Local Farm Supply and Grain Marketing Cooperatives. Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics, 39(1): 201-210.
Cadudal, F., and Couderc, J. P. (2008). Analyse financière des structures aval de la filière viti-vinicole française – Entreprises et coopératives 1998-2007. Montpellier SupAgro and Crédit Agricole SA.
Carlberg, J. G., Word, C. E., and Holcomb, R. B. (2006). Success Factors of New Generation Cooperatives. International Food and Agribusiness Management Review, 9(1): 70-85.
Cook, M. L. (1995). The Future of U.S. Agricultural Cooperatives: A Neo-Institutional Approach. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 77: 1153-1159.
Couret, F. (2006). La démocratie nuit-elle à l’efficacité économique des coopératives? RECMA, 302: 54-66.
Declerck, F., and Viviani, J. L. (2012). Solvency and Performance of French Wineries in Times of Declining Sales: Co-operatives and Corporations. 4th International European Forum on System Dynamics and Innovation, Proceedings in Food System Dynamics 2010, Bonn, Germany.
Dorsey, S., and Boland, M. A. (2009). Vertical Integration in the U.S. Food Economy. Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics, 41: 585-598.
Featherstone, A., and Al-Kheraiji A. (1995). Debt and Input Misallocation of Agricultural Supply and Marketing Cooperatives. Applied Economics, 27: 871-878.
Gurung, R. K., and Unterschultz, J. R. (2007). Evaluation of Factors Affecting the Choice of Pricing and Payment Practices by Traditional Marketing and New Generation Cooperatives, Journal of Cooperatives, 20: 18-32.
Hailu, G., Jeffrey, S., Goddard, E., and Ng, D. (2005). Regulatory Environment, Cooperative Structure, and Agency Costs for Cooperative Agribusiness Firms in Canada: Comparative Case Studies. Journal of Food Distribution Research, 36(2): 39-49.
International Co-operative Alliance, Factsheet. (2012).
International Organization of Vine and Wine Report. (2013).
Ijere, M. O. (1978). New Trends in African Cooperatives: The Nigerian Experience. Fourth Dimension Publishers.
Karantinis, K., and Nilsson, J. (2007). Vertical Markets and Cooperative Hierarchies. The Role of Cooperatives in the Agrifood Industry. Dordrecht, the Netherlands, Springer.
Kenkel, P., Gilbert, A., and Spence, B. (2002). Post Merger Financial Performance of Oklahoma Cooperatives. Southwestern Economics Association, Mobile, AL.
Lazikova, J., Bandlerova, A., and Schwarcz, P. (2008). Agricultural Cooperatives and their Development after the Transformation. Tradition and Innovation. International Scientific Conference of Agricultural Economists, Szent Istvan University, December 3-4, 2007.
Lerman, Z., and Parliament, C. (1990). Comparative Performance of Cooperatives and Investor- Owned Firms in US Food Industries. Agribusiness, 6(6): 527-540.
Li, Z., Keri, J., and Artz, G. M. (2014). The Relative Capital Structure of Agricultural Grain and Supply Cooperatives and Investor Owned Firms. Department of Economics, Iowa State University.
McKee, G. (2007). The Financial Performance of North Dakota Agricultural Cooperatives. Department of Agricultural Economics North Dakota State University, Agribusiness and Applied Economics Report No: 624.
McKee, G. (2008). The Financial Performance of North Dakota Grain Marketing and Farm Supply Cooperatives. Journal of Cooperatives, 21: 15-34.
Mediobanca (2014). Wine Industry Survey April 2014.
Mellor, J. W. (1980). The Economics of Agricultural Development. Cornell University Press, Ithaca and London.
Parliament, C., Lerman, Z., and Fulton J. (1990). Performance of Cooperatives and Investor-owned Firms in the Dairy Industry. Journal of Agricultural Cooperation, 5: 1-6.
Ozudogru, H. (2004). Economic Analysis of Kirklareli Koy-Coop. Union and Examined of Influences to Cooperative Success of Managers. Journal of Turkish Cooperation Institution PhD Thesis, Ankara University, p. 172, Ankara.
Pashkova, N., Niklis, D., Alexakis, D., and Papandreou, A. (2009). Food Marketing Cooperatives of Crete. A Financial Assessment within the EU Context. 113th EAAE Seminar, September 3-6, 2009, Chania, Crete, Greece.
Richards, T., and Manfredo, M. (2002). Post-Merger Performance of Agricultural Cooperatives. Agricultural Finance Review, 63(2):175-192.
Schrader, L., Babb, E. M., Boynton R. D., and Lang, M. G. (1985). Cooperative and Proprietary Agribusiness: Comparison of Performance. Research Bulletin 982, Purdue University, Agricultural Experiment Station, West Lafayette, Indiana.
Shermain, D. H., and Vikas, D. S. (2007). Most West Coast Agricultural Cooperatives are Financially Competitive. California Agriculture, 61(4): 172-176.
Schumacher, S., and Boland, M. A. (2005). Persistence in Profitability in Food and Agribusiness Firms. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 87(1): 103-115.
Sergaki, P., and Semos, A. (2006). The Greek Unions of Agricultural Cooperatives as Efficient Enterprises. Agricultural Economics Review, 7(2): 15-27.
Sexton, R., and Iskow J. (1993). What Do We Know About the Economic Efficiency of Cooperatives: An Evaluative Survey. Journal of Agricultural Cooperation, 8: 15-27.
Soboh, R. A. M. E., Lansink, A. O., Giesen, G., and Van Dijk, G. (2009). Performance Measurement of the Agricultural Marketing Cooperatives: The Gap between Theory and Practice. Review of Agricultural Economics, 31(2): 446-469.
Stevens, R. D., and Jabara, C. L. (1988). Agricultural Development Principles. Economic Theory and Empirical Evidence. The Johns Hopkins University Press. Baltimore and London.
Surmeli, Y. (2006). Cooperative Management Analysis of Afyon Basmakci, Msc Thesis. Ankara University, pp 130, Ankara.
Swaminathan, A., and Delacroix, D. (1991). Differentiation within an Organizational Population: Additional Evidence from the Wine Industry. The Academy of Management Journal, 34(3): 679-692.
United Nations. (2001). Resolution 56/114 adopted in December 2001.
In-Text Citation: (Fazzini & Russo, 2014)
To Cite this Article: Fazzini, M., & Russo, A. (2014). Profitability in the Italian Wine Sector: An Empirical Analysis of Cooperatives and Investor-Owned Firms. International Journal of Academic Research in Accounting Finance and Management Sciences, 4(3), 176–186.
Copyright: © 2018 The Author(s)
Published by Human Resource Management Academic Research Society (www.hrmars.com)
This article is published under the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY 4.0) license. Anyone may reproduce, distribute, translate and create derivative works of this article (for both commercial and non-commercial purposes), subject to full attribution to the original publication and authors. The full terms of this license may be seen at: http://creativecommons.org/licences/by/4.0/legalcode